First of all, i was about to start a thread like "New player feedback" and that was why I logged on forums. I am very happy that this thread is already here and what is even better, started by staff.
I am new to Evolution (10 days), but i played UO on like 10 servers (UO Forever, Paradise Found, Dark Paradise etc.) for over 6 years, so i believe i have some experience with different approach and different systems that somewhere worked, where some did not.
The most positive things I saw in these days:
1, Staff - It is not usual to see staff like Evo have, staff that actually cares. Listening to Dante (and Kane) on TS at that meeting 2 days back was really interesting. Not only because of things that he was discussing, but mostly because of his approach. I could clearly see, that he is open to discussions, suggestions and even a normal chat. He explained, he asked our opinions, he cared. That was a very positive thing to see, for me. I didn't see this approach on any other server i played... this Staff/player friendly approach.
2, Custom stuff - Simply, amazing. I can't even imagine how much work you guys had to do.. Pets, keys, quests, skills, spells and i believe much more i didn't find out yet. I really like it. Playing UO for 6 years might get boring, so experiencing something new is very refreshing and welcome.
3, Playerbase - One of the best playersbase i saw. People are friendly, helpful, generous. Didn't meet any PK yet (those always anger me =D). Players are very important part of UO server, and i think Evo has really a good ones.
Negative things I experienced in my 10 days on Evo:
I have to say, that i think it is not possible to make a server that suits 100% to everyone. People have different needs, people having fun doing different things... and that means that sometimes we all probably experience a moment or a thing, that we don't like, but we will get over it or get used to it.
There is however one thing, that im still fighting with and can't get over it or used to it - The power of donation.
Please read my donation philosophy for an explanation
http://uoevolution.com/wiki/index.php/Donation_Philosophy
Let me explain...
I completely understand that running a server like this costs money (owners money). And not only the money, it costs hell lot of time and dedication to create a server like Evo is. BUT, now in 2015, when gaming pay2win model barely exists, i found it here :-/
FYI we are not a pay-to-win model we are a custom free-to-play ultima online shard. You can obtain every item in game through hard work and game play. You can earn/find Evolution dollars in game to purchase anything from the player economy
Quote from wiki:
"Evolution Dollars can be obtained by Donating, participating in staff events, random drop from voting, random drop from Felucca dungeon chests, daily ED raffle stone, auctions, buy from players, the custom treasure maps and in the loot packs of the Felucca custom Bosses"
No other shard has EVER offered players a way to obtain donation currency in-game without ever having to donate. UO Evolution is the only shard, with a donation model, that is truly free-to-play (f2p)
You can also buy EDs from many players who do support the shard with donations. I also offer every item in game through the auction and sell for gold, to help balance the economy(I do this to be fair, provide a gold sink and to allow non-donors to have rares available)
Most of the new games released in past 3 years are focusing on free to play model, with some boosts for money, to save time for lazy ones =) It is not that i wouldn't like to pay for a game or support developers (i think you Dante/Kane deserve money for your great work more than others), but when i decide i'd like to play a free to play shard/game.. i expect that i will be normal player and not a "weakling forced to pay or die" because of that.
I was here like 2 days when i maxed out my fighting skills, magic skills, got my starting gear from New dungeon and i started to look around about which way should i develop my character. I always liked tamers and pets, so i started to look for a good pet to get... asked players, asked in guild and what i found was very disappointing. The best pets, pet leveling deeds and pet slots that character can increase is all for donation ONLY.
They did not provide you with true information. There are many powerful pets you can easily tame and breed. Many players obtain greater dragons, cu sidhes, ancient firesteeds and ice hounds. Many other players use the bioengineer to create "donation" quality pets, all with no donations
Each month i run event for the rare pets, like the "full moon" werewolf hunt and "safari" events (see the wiki for event details)
I also make donation/rare pets available as spawns in game, you can buy from players, or at auctions for gold
This totally ruined my plan about having best pet and fighting this way...
Warrior that solos champ (needs one handed scroll etc.) You don't need One-hand deed to do a champ...I soloed the same champs for years without one-hand deeds. We added those as an enhancement to make a nicer champ weapon, but by no means a requirement
Archer have the same problem... So far as i saw, there is a possibility to obtain these items even without donation.
There is a need for great breeders/crafters for the new players that arrive, you can make a ton on gold/ed selling hard to craft items and pets
Because of ED and auction, there is a "chance" to get these... BUT, The problem is, that donors and veterans are farming 100x times faster than me, which means they farm 1m gold while I farm 10k. This leads to a fact, that if someone will be selling ED's, there will be always someone who will pay more than me.
I know you are feeling a disconnect between being a new player and a veteran player. You have to remember you are playing on a shard that has players, playing daily for 4 years and have acquired a lot of gold and items. You are brand new and are shooting for an end-game item your first week. This shard is designed to be an enjoyable journey...You don't want to get all the top items too quickly and ruin the fun of the game. Pace yourself, there are many ways to get items and wealth
Im not sure if you see where am i pointing with this - Basically i feel i have no chance to "catch up" to donators and veterans.
There is no need to feel like you have to "catch up", this is a solo experience with no time limits
There is plenty of stuff that makes player strong - Donation pets, Dragon cloaks, newly introduced Black Belt, high-end dungeon artifacts... But, i can't get these items in any short time.
You are not meant to get these items...yet
My only chance is to farm, go through low dungeons like Shame/Destard/Despise and gather the gold and maybe one days after a year of farming, i'll buy something to make me stronger and be able to progress to harder dungeons...
Yes! you are a new player and SHOULD be going to the low level dungeons! It won't take a year I promise!
But meanwhile a well geared player will earn 100x more than me in the same time and this makes prices to grow, because people having more money = people are willing to spend more money for something.. I see the only chance to catch up if they would stop farming for months, which they won't =)
The Auction is great (i've been on 2 auctions made by staff so far) but saw the same problem.. Good stuff, but people are throwing like 40 millions on a single item... How can i even bid against these people?
The auctions are really not meant for new players, tough to compete your first week here. I went through the same discouragement on other shards before making this one. I also disliked the feeling on "never" getting to buy anything, but as an owner I found the auctions necessary. The auctions are ways for me to control the economy and suck all the excess gold out (called "gold sinks")
So after 10 days, im asking myself a question.. Will i ever be able to get donation items? Yes! Will i ever be able to compete against others? Yes! we had 347 players online and were ALL new players at one time!
Will i ever be able to enjoy the full game and not just a part of it? The full game is enjoyed one step at a time, not in giant leaps to the end. There are many things the donors miss out on by trying to get stuff too fast, and skipping all the mid-level content.
I completely understand that i need to work for it, months, maybe years.. And i have no problem with it and i will enjoy playing meanwhile, but i need some kind of a "goal".. There are many goals here...craft a level 100 weapon, craft a black belt, craft a dragon cloak, make a bioengineered pet, collect ED for that werewolf you have your eye on? All obtainable goals without any donation...and those are all end-game items!
Put this in a real-world perspective, if you want a Ferrari you have to work hard and save up for that dream. You can't expect to get one with your first paycheck.
To continue this analogy, you cant get upset if some rich, young guy, buys that Ferrari today, and it takes you 20 years of hard work and saving to get yours...
To take it one step further, if the rich Ferrari owner (donor) made it possible for you (non-donor) to get your own Ferrari? Would you be happy? Without him (donor) you could NEVER have a Ferrari...there would be no dealership (uoe server)?
You should be happy, this system works completely in your favor...you play for FREE:)
For example, if there would be even a ridiculous price for donation stuff in gold (lets say 10-15 million gold - that is a lot for me, but you can move this price where ever you want).. i would have goal. You can easily buy ED from players with gold. Players do quests make bios and collect rares which can be sold in-game for ED
I would know that i want a pet and im going forward to it by every single gold coin i collect. But now i have a feeling, that i will never get EDs to buy one. Cause with EDs i have to rely, that someone else will be selling them and that another players will not offer more than me... Which seems very unlikely with huge difference of gold players have and rate they are acquiring it. And mining 6 months to be able to overprice a single deal and get 1 item i want.. No, i don't want to mine 6 months.
Explained pros and cons, suggestion now =)
I understand that changing anything based on one or few players feedback is unlikely, but as you surprised me with your approach to players, i had a need to give you my feedback, after 10 days of playing, to at least open a discussion and hear your (and other players) thoughts.
I don't mean anything bad with it.. If i should say one single word about Evolution shard, i would say "Fantastic!" ... I really love many things here =) I do thank you for taking the time to write this post, we do listen
But i also admit, that im not sure if i should continue playing, because i can't get over the donation / veteran farming stuff i mentioned above. I don't know if i will ever get them, that is whats bothering me the most (no better future). Since this is the only thing that bothers me so much, i would suggest releasing strongest items to all people (even for very high prices) and balancing the gold amount of new players vs veterans have and mostly, balancing its farm rate.
It doesn't matter is we have 0 players online or 300 online, there is still amazing content for you to enjoy for FREE. It's not a competition. Some players skip the grind by donating, others earn it through the enjoyment of playing the game.
Why would it really matter if someone earned an item in game or donated for it? Everyone is having fun and the players that do donate are making the shard FREE for those that can't afford to donate
If we did not accept donations at all, and players had to EARN all of their wealth, would you be upset that a player spent 40 million on an item at auction? Probably not...
Also i understand that changing anything in donation system could have influence on profit, which i understand is unwanted (and i agree). I wish i knew a way, how to keep donation rate or even make it higher, while allowing stuff to all players, not only donators =)
So far, im training and willing to try and enjoy more of Evolution shard, want to give it a chance and hope, that the only thing that bothers me somehow disappears or i'll get over it, somehow =)
Anyway, if you made it through this wall of text, i congratulate you! =D
Also my apologies for any typo or bad grammar.. English is not my native language and i still have a lot to learn =) Hopefully everything was understandable. FYI I did edit the spelling and grammar for an easier read, hope you don't mind
Have a nice day!
Sargoth =)
Thank you for your feedback, I appreciate you taking the time to write such a detailed post