Kyn, the issue is that when i create a weapon with valorite, or platinum - the name is not correct. Neither is the hue. It should have a blue or white hue according to the ore used.
I find the stats below par aswell tbh, granted it's luck - but making 200 weapons should yield a decent weapon i think.
i make exceptional radiant scimitars, but they look like plain (none colored ingot) ones. I ABSOLUTELY am sure i'm using valorite and platinum ingots, because when i smelt the weapons in a salvage bag, i get valorite and/or platinum returned respectively.
atm i have a bag in my backpack with 34 weapons that i made, and as you can see most of them are called radiant scimitar. Take one, smelt it in a salvage back and watch what you get back. If there's no issue, then a "Radiant Scimitar" should return iron ingots, but the ones i created return plat and valorite because that's what they're crafted with.
i'm out for the afternoon, but i left my game running so you can have a look at it when you have time.
thanx.